Otterbein St Marys Retirement Community
St Marys, OH · Medicare and Medicaid-certified nursing home (CCN 365953) · 53 certified beds
Health inspection: 4 · Quality measures: 4 · Staffing: 3
Federal fines: none on current record
Phone: (419) 394-6330 · Verify on Medicare Care Compare ↗
Otterbein St Marys Retirement Community holds a CMS overall star rating of 4 out of 5, above the Ohio state average of 3.15. Its health inspection rating is 4 stars and its staffing rating is 3 stars.
Otterbein St Marys Retirement Community reports total nurse staffing of about 3.49 hours per resident per day, including 0.79 RN hours per resident per day, with a staffing star rating of 3. Nursing staff turnover is reported at 34.0%.
Otterbein St Marys Retirement Community has no federal fines on record — 0 fines totaling $0.00 — and no payment denials. CMS does not show an abuse icon or Special Focus status for this facility in the available data.
About this facility
Otterbein St Marys Retirement Community is a for-profit nursing home in St Marys, Auglaize County, Ohio, certified for both Medicare and Medicaid since February 1994. The facility is certified for 53 beds and has an average daily census of 49.7 residents.
According to CMS Care Compare, the facility holds an overall star rating of 4 out of 5, above the Ohio state average of 3.15. Its component ratings are: health inspection rating of 4, quality measure rating of 4, and staffing rating of 3.
Nurse staffing data show total nurse hours per resident per day of approximately 3.49, including about 0.79 RN hours per resident per day. Nursing staff turnover is reported at 34.0%.
Regarding penalties, CMS records show 0 federal fines totaling $0.00 and 0 payment denials — no federal fines on record for this facility. There is no abuse icon flagged and no Special Focus Facility status noted in the provided data.
Otterbein St Marys is part of the Otterbein Seniorlife chain, which operates 20 facilities with an average CMS rating of 3.2 across the chain. There has been no change of ownership in the past 12 months, so current ratings reflect the current operator.
This profile is based on data from CMS Medicare Care Compare; families are encouraged to verify current details directly on Care Compare before making a decision.
Questions families ask
What is this nursing home's CMS overall star rating and how does it compare to the state average?
It has an overall rating of 4 out of 5 stars, which is above the Ohio state average of 3.15.
Does this facility accept Medicare, Medicaid, or both?
It accepts both Medicare and Medicaid.
How well is this facility staffed — nurse hours per resident and turnover?
Total nurse staffing is about 3.49 hours per resident per day, with 0.79 RN hours per resident per day, and staff turnover is 34.0%. The staffing star rating is 3.
Does this facility have federal fines or penalties on record?
No, CMS records show 0 fines totaling $0.00 and no payment denials.
Has CMS flagged this facility for abuse or placed it in the Special Focus program?
No abuse icon or Special Focus status is indicated in the CMS data for this facility.
How large is this facility and how many residents live there?
It is certified for 53 beds with an average daily census of 49.7 residents.
Who owns this facility — and is it part of a chain?
It is a for-profit corporation and part of the Otterbein Seniorlife chain, which includes 20 facilities with an average CMS rating of 3.2.
How long has this facility been Medicare/Medicaid certified?
It has been certified since February 9, 1994.
What do the four different CMS star ratings mean?
CMS rates facilities on overall quality, health inspections, staffing, and quality measures; this facility scores 4, 4, 3, and 4 respectively.
Does this facility offer short-term rehabilitation as well as long-term care?
The data provided does not specify service lines; contact the facility at 4193946330 or check Medicare Care Compare at https://www.medicare.gov/care-compare/details/nursing-home/365953?state=OH to confirm.
What should I look for when touring this facility?
The data provided does not cover tour details; contact the facility at 4193946330 to arrange a visit and verify current conditions.
How do I verify this facility's current record on Medicare Care Compare?
You can review the latest ratings and inspection details at https://www.medicare.gov/care-compare/details/nursing-home/365953?state=OH.
Data: CMS Care Compare (Aug2026 refresh). Star ratings, staffing hours, and penalty records are CMS's official published measures. Always tour the facility, review the current inspection record, and verify details with Medicare before making care decisions.